Brunch at Le Comptoir de Pierre Gagnaire in Shanghai

To complete my Shanghai Michelin Guide Scrambled I made a reservation at Le Comptoir de Pierre Gagnaire in Shanghai for a Sunday lunch. The restaurant was given a star in the 2019 editoon of the Shanghai Michelin Guide and is located in the exclusive Capella Hotel in the former French Concession.

According to his Wikipedia entry

Gagnaire is an iconoclastic chef at the forefront of the fusion cuisine movement. Beginning his career in St. Etienne where he won three Michelin Stars, Gagnaire tore at the conventions of classic French cooking by introducing jarring juxtapositions of flavours, tastes, textures, and ingredients.

Spoiler alert: nothing of this was apparent in the restaurant I visited.

The visit

My first attempt to make a reservation was weird. I called and was told that it was possible to join for lunch. But when I replied that I would come at noon, at the opening time, I was told that they could only accommodate me at 12.30. To me that does not make any sense. If you have a table at 12.30, then it must available also at half an hour earlier (since it is the opening time…).

I completed my reservation by email.

When I arrived I discovered that the menu that I had consulted on the website was only available for dinner! There was a less interesting brunch menu available. Later I complained about this with the manager and I see that now they published on the Capella’s page for the restaurant all the various menus. You are welcome.

I settled for their brunch package that included two courses, mineral water, juices, tea or coffee, bread basket, and desserts from a mini buffet. Then, I also added some eggs from la carte.

The bread basket was promptly served with butter and some confectioneries. Nice, but nothing spectacular.

Then I got their signature beef tartare. It is tartare with some additional ingredients, such as cheese, tuna and duck sashimi. Iconoclast? I was expecting a lot, but please give the Le Bec tartare every day of the week over this.

Next I got a sea bream seared fillet with a delicious condiment. This was a very good dish, but nothing new.

The Egg Benedict were perfectly executed.

Finally, I sampled some cakes from the dessert buffet. Again, very good, but nothing that left me with the crave to go back.

The check

Final charge was 644.60 CNY (94 USD). The basic package was 488 CNY plus 10% service charge.

What to say? For a brunch in Shanghai, this is a pretty bad value for money. For that money you can dine in a luxury buffet on the Bund (hint… check the Cathay Room).

Did I find anything exceptional about this French restaurant? Not really, I can have a good sea bream fillet in so many other establishments. If I could sample the full menu, who knows, maybe I would have had a better experience.

Why a place like this gets a star and Villa Le Bec does not will remain a mystery to me. Unfortunately, the Shanghai inspectors seem to be prone to award stars by default to the branches of renowned international powerhouses.

Where in Shanghai:
480 Jianguo Xi Lu inside Capella Hotel
Address in Chinese: 建国西路480号(建业里)
Check the hotel website page for the restaurant.

 

 

Feasting on luxury dim sum at Seventh Son, Shanghai

Continuing the Shanghai Michelin Guide Scramble, this time I visited Seventh Son. It was a Saturday for lunch, so the fact that the establishment is famous for their dim sum was very fitting. Seventh Son is a chain of Cantonese restaurants that originated from Hong Kong and they have branches also in Japan and in Beijing and Shenzhen. In Shanghai they have two locations and only the one at the Kerry Centre (in Jingan) gained a Michelin star (the other is located inside the Shanghri-la in Pudong).

The visit

I had made a reservation with a phone call (the website did not work when I tried, now seems fine). I arrived punctual like a Swiss watch at 11.30 and my name was not on their reservation list. But no worries, they still had space for me. It is a large dining room, but it did fill quickly as expected on a weekend.

Reading the three or four menus I was handed required its fair share of time. They have an impressive array of options. In the end I ordered mostly from their dim sum menu. After completing my order the waiter commented that I must have not been hungry… that I found very funny since I ordered a ton of food. But I soon noticed that other guests would order even more and then take the left over at home. Not my modus operandi.

I first got the stir-fried turnip cakes. Six pieces. All delicious (I could not imagine turnip could be so good).

Then I got a dim sum classic like the shrimp dumplings. Good, but not particularly impressive.

The spring rolls (recommended by the waiter) were remarkable. I have eaten them dozens of times, but never with such a thin and crispy pastry.

Finally I had one of their most popular dishes, the crispy fried chicken (half). The skin was similar to the one that you usually get with the suckling and very tasty. Unfortunately, not sure why, but in the end there was not much meat.

The check

The bill came at 492.80 CNY (70 USD). This is high-end Cantonese cuisine and you can expect this price point for dim sum. If you start ordering abalone and bird’s nest dishes of course the bill will be much higher.

I certainly enjoyed to try some high-end dim sum. I am not an expert, but I could taste the difference with cheaper versions that I had elsewhere. I would recommend going in a group and trying several dim sum dishes.

Where in Shanghai:
1515 NanJing West Road, Jing’An, Jing’An Kerry Centre 2F
For reservation and more information check their website.

Superb Cantonese food at Ji Ping Court, Shanghai

Continuing the Shanghai Michelin Guide Scramble, I visited Ji Ping Court on a Monday for lunch. The restaurant is located on the third floor of a newly-built luxury building at 55 South Wulumuqi Road in the Former French Concession. It had one star in the 2019 edition of the Michelin Guide that became 2 in the 2020 edition.

Ji Ping Court is a new addition to the 2019 Michelin Guide and gained one star.

The dining room is elegant and intimate and tables are reasonably spaced. They also have three or four private dining rooms.

The visit

I booked by phone calling at around 9.30am and someone was already there to answer the phone. I arrived at around 11.30 and by noon the restaurant was bustling with action. Two of the private rooms were occupied and there were only a couple of tables free in main dining room.

I spent sometime on the exhaustive menu that includes all the classic Cantonese delicacies, including dim sum, and some original dishes.

I ordered one of their creative dishes in the form of a salad with marinated goose liver and grapefruit (but in the menu was indicated as pomelo). The goose liver came in cubes and the overall salad was fresh and tasty. This appropriately was the first dish to arrive.

Then I had a very classic crab soup with corn. This is a very common dish in China and I totally enjoyed it.

Then I had their braised beef brisket with daikon. It came in a pot in a soup full of flavors. While the brisket was not of the melt-in-your-mouth type, the pieces were mostly lean and absolutely tasty.

But the big-ticket item was their trio of Cantonese-style roast meat. From left to right, the dish sported roasted duck, roasted suckling pig and BBQ pork. I tried these types of meat in many other establishments and I can say that what I got was considerably superior to what you would get in the run-of-the-mill Chinese restaurant in Shanghai or even Guangzhou. The duck in particular did not come with any bone and was very tender and juicy. As you would expect the suckling skin was perfectly crispy.

I decided to close the meal with a panna cotta with strawberry that was also perfect.

The check

For what it was a very large meal for one person I paid 715 CNY or just a little over 100 USD. This was a luxury restaurant so this price point is expected. However, considering the quality of the offering, I do not regret this expense.

Overall, the experience was positive and I would have no reservations in recommending this restaurant for high quality Cantonese food. I hope to go back to try their dim sum dishes since what I could try in this visit is just a tiny sample of their large menu.

Also I had a positive experience with the service personnel that was attentive and spoke English, way better than in similar Shanghai restaurants.

Where in Shanghai:
3F, 55 South Wulumuqi Road, Xuhui
Info from the online Michelin Guide.

Every dish a masterpiece at Taian Table in Shanghai

Taian Table debuted in mid 2016 and by October had gained a star in the inaugural edition of the Shanghai’s Michelin Guide. The restaurant, the brainchild of German chef Stefan Stiller, was named after Tai’an road, where it was initially located. The current location is on Zhenning Road, near Xinzha Road in Changning District in an office complex. The restaurant has retained its star in the second and third edition of the Shanghai Michelin Guide. This review is part of the Shanghai Michelin Guide Scramble. UPDATE: Deservedly, the restaurant got two stars in the 2020 edition of the Guide.

What is special about Taian Table that intrigued me was their changing menu. In some of these fine dining venues, modifications of the menu are infrequent if not rare. Contrast this with Taian Table team that, since its opening, has minted 17 different menus, sometimes with profound changes. This is an impressive degree of creativity. Even better, I love the current format. While Taian Table is a classic multi-course dining experience, only 8 dishes are fixed, then each guest can customize his/her selection with 2, 4 or 6 additional dishes chosen from “classics” and “specials”.

The visit

I booked through the website and it was very simple. I had to put down a 500 CNY deposit for each guest (I and a friend) that was easy to pay electronically.

I and my friend arrived at around 7pm and were welcomed in the dining room dominated by two L shaped counters enclosing the open kitchen. The counter sported high chairs, which I usually hate, but these were comfortable (also thanks to a foot rest space placed on the counter base).

We were immediately welcomed with the initial “snacks and nibbles”: some honey-glazed nuts and crackers with flavor coming from nori and kombu seaweeds. The nuts were nuts, but the crackers were remarkable, with a decisive “sea” flavor.

As part of these initial snacks we were offered a cappuccino with foie gras, chicken stock and Parmesan emulsion and some bread crumbs. It was something delicious.

More nibbles were waiting for us with a trio: a dumpling with tomato extract (I think reminiscent of Italian fagottini), a pastry with vitello tonnato and a salmon tart.

At this point we also had a chance to know the chef in charge of the kitchen, Mr Johnny Pham. Johnny would personally explain each dish to us throughout the rest of the evening.

The first “institutional” dish was called Foie Gras Snow. Foie gras flakes were covering a layer of lychee panna cotta and Riesling jelly. The dish was very refreshing, with no single flavor dominating others.

Next came a small work of art: thin slices of char fish (a freshwater fish found in cold mountain lakes) enclosed in equally thin slices of cucumber (and with trout roe on top). I admired this dish, but honestly it was probably my least favorite as I prefer stronger flavors.

The third dish consisted in snails covered in parsley. The white pearls in the dish were made of garlic. I am not a big fan of snails, but with these dressings they were very pleasant to eat.

At this point I was served the first of my two “free” dishes: a spoon of sea urchin on sour-dough bread (that appeared to be caramelized I think thanks to brown butter) and capped with a slice of apple. I ate it in two bites and I found that the sour-dough greatly enhanced the sea urchin flavor.

My friend opted for a piece of seared foie gras.

Then we went back to a dish made with French components with a bite of Dover sole and mussels in a sauce made with daikon and dill-oil. This was incredibly satisfying.

Then there was some more sea waiting with a charcoal grilled turbot fish on a layer of sauerkraut and capped with a teaspoon of caviar.

My friend opted for a bite of lobster (again in dill-oil).

The next masterpiece was the chef’s interpretation of the classic Oeuf en Meurette. In this case the poached egg came with a slice of crispy Parma ham and a wine sauce with pickled Shimeji mushrooms. I was later explained by chef Stiller that the pinkish color of the egg is the result of a brining process lasting for about 2-3 hours during which the eggs are soaked in a mix of beetroot juice and reduced port-wine. The inspiration coming from the Chinese Tea Egg.

Now time for a sorbet: a watermelon sorbet served with some borage (and at the perfect temperature).

But before entering the final act, we were served another big ticket item: a bite of slow-cooked beef short-rib with various condiments such as celeriac mash, chanterelle, and crispy beef tendon. I was able to cut the meat with my chopsticks.

Th last official dish was called ‘Îles flottantes’ (Floating island) and was a glorious lemon sorbet with various fruit condiments.

In the closing act, we were offered a trio of mini sweet pastries, a selection of chocolate pralines and a stick with cotton candy. More than enough to satisfy my sweet tooth.

The check

We spent 1228 CNY (177 USD) per person that was the cost of the 10 course menu (including two dishes chosen from the list of the classics). We did not drink wine and we relied on the house water. This means that this was the absolute minimum to dine at the restaurant. We opted for the 10 course menu with the idea to throw in a couple of additional dishes if we felt like it, but by mid-dinner we realized that 10 courses were more than enough for our appetite. Special appreciation for the staff that was very professional and not pushy in asking us to order wine or cocktails. I can only recommend to go for dinner with an healthy appetite since every dish is just phenomenal and it would not have been bad to try the 12 course option.

Of course 1228 is a handsome sum for a dinner, but I think the value and the creativity of the offering justify the price point. Many of these dishes required hours of preparation. Every single dish was unique and creative and, overall, provided a nice balance between Eastern and Westerner flavors.

I wish Stefan, Johnny and their team continued success as I would totally go back to try one of their future menus if I have a chance.

Where in Shanghai:
465 Zhenning Road, Lane No 161, 101-102, Building No 1
Address in Chinese: 上海市长宁区镇宁路4651611号楼101-102
Pro-tip: the restaurant does not seem to be listed on Didi, the Chinese Uber. If you use Didi, you can indicate “Anken South Gate”: the entrance of this complex is next to the location of the restaurant.
Reservation and menu on the restaurant’s website.

The Shanghai Michelin Guide Scramble

Challenge completed in October 2019. Read my final reflection

This post is to announce the following challenge: in the next year or so Check Please will dine at each and every Michelin-starred restaurant in Shanghai. Ideally, the quest will be completed by October 2019 (to keep it restrained to the current edition of the Guide), however we might go beyond this period.

This means visiting a total of 34 restaurants (this number was 30 last year and 26 in the previous year’s inaugural edition). With an average of 3 restaurants per month it should be achievable in one year.

I have listed below the target restaurants according to the 2019 Michelin Guide for Shanghai. I will italicize the restaurants that I have visited and link to their reviews as I go. Some have been visited prior of establishing this blog, but I was able to publish a review with original photos (in some cases take by friends dining with me).

Please note that I am excluding from this challenge the Bib Gourmands and other restaurants listed on the Guide without any star.

I will call the challenge The Shanghai Michelin Guide Scramble. Disclaimer: I am in no way associated with the Michelin Guide.

Three Stars 
Ultraviolet 

Two Stars 
8 ½ Otto e Mezzo Bombana 
Canton 8 (Runan Street)
Imperial Treasure
L’Atelier de Joel Robuchon
T’ang Court
Xin Rong Ji (Nanyang Road) (New)
Yi Long Court
Yong Foo Elite

One Star 

Amazing Chinese Cuisine (New)
Bo Shanghai
Da Dong (Xuhui)
Da Dong (Jingnan)
Fu He Hui
Il Ristorante – Niko Romito (New)
Jade Mansion
Jean Georges 
Ji Pin Court (New)
Lao Zheng Xing (Huangpu)
Le Comptoir de Pierre Gagnaire (New)
Le Patio & La Famille (Huangpu)
Lei Garden (Xuhui)
Lei Garden (Pudong)
Madam Goose (Minhang)
Moose (New)
Phenix 
Seventh Son (Jingan)
Shang High Cuisine
Sir Elly’s
Taian Table 
Wujie (Huangpu)
Xin Rong Ji (Huangou)
Yong Fu
Yong Yi Ting

Brunch at the Phénix – Shanghai

The Phénix Eatery and Bar is the flagship restaurant of the luxurious Puli hotel in Shanghai. They were awarded one star in the 2018 Shanghai Michelin guide that was confirmed in 2019. I also visited them for dinner.

The visit

I had heard that they had started offering Sunday brunches and I had been thinking of trying for a while. On a sunny Sunday of June the stars aligned and I showed up.

They are one of the many establishments now offering a “semi-buffet”. It works like this: you order a couple of dishes from a menu (usually the choice is quite limited) and while you wait for the hot dishes you can indulge yourself in a buffet with exquisite sides and cold dishes.

The Phénix follows this format. The menu is based on breakfast dishes (from omelettes to tartares). You can choose two mains and a dessert from the menu and have fun with their buffet spread.

From the menu I chose an omlette (with a hint of truffle) and a beef tartare. Small portions. Done by the book. From the buffet I chose to try their oysters, a quiche Lorraine, cheese (they had five or six types available, more than the average buffet in Shanghai), cold cuts (in particular some ham) and some other random stuff. I certainly enjoyed the dessert from the menu, a nicely made chocolate cake.

Juices and tea/coffee were also included. You can check the menu on their website.

The check

The final check was 545 RMB and changes (around 85 USD). When I think about it, I cannot complain about anything, but at the same time there was nothing that stood up and made me think: “I need to come back for it!” I guess the brunch is not indicative of the cuisine that won them the Michelin star. Would I go back? No, in Shanghai there are way better choices for less that money (the weekend buffet at the Kitchen Studios at the Andaz hotel comes to my mind as the best deal at the moment and it is a bona fide full buffet; for a semi-buffet, with a little bit more the Cathay Room at the Peace Hotel offers a choice of more substantial dishes). Subsequently I also had dinner with them and I was equally not that impressed. I might go back to try their full fledged menu though.

Where in Shanghai:
2/F, 1 Changde Lu, near Yan’an Xi Lu
常德路1号璞麗酒店二楼, 近延安西路